Business Details
18 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in St. Marys, ON
St Marys Insurance Group was formed in 2008 through the amalgamation of Stonetown Insurance Brokers and Thames Valley Insurance Brokers. We operate as a full-service general insurance brokerage with six licensed brokers, serving clients in St. Marys and Stratford. Our team brings over 175 years of combined experience in property and casualty insurance across personal and commercial lines. We prioritize unbiased advice, continuous education, and community engagement, treating clients as valued neighbors rather than mere customers. Our commitment extends beyond insurance, pledging to enhance the St. Marys community through dedicated resources and local partnerships.
Services
Car Insurance
Home Insurance
Business Insurance
High Risk Auto Insurance
Collector Car Insurance
Travel Trailer Insurance
Snowmobile Insurance
ATV Insurance
Tenant Insurance
Condo Insurance
Details
- Year established: 2008
Highlights and features
- We offer 175+ years of combined insurance expertise in property and casualty coverage.
- Our independent brokerage provides unbiased advice tailored to individual client needs.
- We represent multiple insurers to ensure optimal coverage options for all risk profiles.
- Good driver discounts available with potential savings up to 50% on premiums.
- Community-focused approach with local decision-making and personalized service.
What people say
Competitive rates
Personalized service
Knowledgeable brokers
Community-focused approach
Tailored coverage options
Services
Car Insurance
We provide comprehensive car insurance coverage options for standard, high-risk, and collector vehicles. Our policies protect against liability, accidents, and property damage while offering discounts for safe drivers and multi-vehicle bundling. With access to multiple insurers, we help clients find competitive rates tailored to their specific driving profiles and coverage needs.
Home Insurance
Our home insurance solutions cover residential properties against risks like fire, theft, and natural disasters. Policies include protection for primary residences, condos, cottages, and rental properties with customizable coverage for personal belongings and liability. We help clients understand policy details including deductibles, exclusions, and additional endorsements for high-value items.
Business Insurance
We offer customized business insurance packages for enterprises of all sizes, covering risks related to property damage, liability, and operational disruptions. Our commercial policies protect against lawsuits, equipment damage, and industry-specific hazards while providing options for fleet vehicles, professional liability, and environmental risks. We work closely with clients to create risk management strategies that align with their business objectives.
High Risk Auto Insurance
Specialized insurance solutions for drivers with at-fault accidents, traffic convictions, or policy cancellations. We partner with insurers that accommodate high-risk profiles to provide necessary coverage while helping clients understand factors affecting their premiums. Our brokers work to find the most suitable options based on individual driving histories and vehicle types.
Collector Car Insurance
Tailored insurance for vintage and collector vehicles meeting specific criteria including age, usage, and driver experience. Our policies provide appropriate coverage for classic cars with modified terms reflecting their limited use and higher value. We assist collectors in determining eligibility and securing competitive rates for their specialty vehicles.
People
Sheri Unich
Broker
Experienced insurance broker specializing in auto coverage solutions with extensive knowledge of high-risk and collector vehicle policies.
Melanie MacLeod
Broker
Dedicated insurance professional providing comprehensive coverage advice for personal and commercial clients with a focus on tailored risk management strategies.
Erica Brine
Owner/Broker
Licensed broker and business owner with expertise in specialty insurance products, committed to delivering personalized service and community-focused solutions.
Questions
What factors affect car insurance rates in Ontario?
Rates depend on coverage type, vehicle details, driving history, location, and usage patterns like commuting versus pleasure driving.
How can I reduce home insurance costs?
Bundle policies, install security systems, increase deductibles, and consult our brokers for personalized discount opportunities.
Is business insurance mandatory in Ontario?
While not legally required, business insurance protects against potentially devastating financial losses from claims or lawsuits.
What qualifies as a collector car?
Typically vehicles 15+ years old with limited use, not exceeding 300 kph top speed, and drivers with 10+ years experience.
Do you offer 24/7 claims support?
Our office hours are 8:30am-4:30pm Mon-Fri, but we provide guidance for after-hours emergency situations through our voicemail system.