Explore the art of the past, present, and future
A Slice of Homegrown Goodness
With humble beginnings in the north end of St. Catharines, Pie Guys Pizzeria blossomed from a local hangout to a beloved pizza institution. Founded on a foundation of authentic family recipes and a genuine love for delicious food, we've grown into a cherished part of the community.
Our Story
The folks behind Pie Guys first joined forces to create a pizzeria that captured the essence of classic Italian flavors. Inspired by generations-old family traditions, they honed their craft, crafting pizzas with fresh, handmade dough and simmering sauces. Their passion resonated with the neighbourhood, quickly establishing Pie Guys as the go-to spot for mouthwatering pizza and wings.
More than just Pizza
But Pie Guys is more than just pizza. It's a place where families gather, friends connect, and memories are made. With a welcoming atmosphere, friendly service, and a wide variety of dishes, we cater to every kind of dining experience.
What We Offer
- Delicious Pizza: From classic pepperoni to specialty creations, our pizzas are hand-tossed and baked fresh with love.
- Fresh Wings: Choose from a variety of flavors and sauces for wing-loving patrons.
- Appetizers, Salads & More: We offer a variety of other delectable dishes, including appetizers, salads, and beverages.
- Family-Friendly Fun: Enjoy your meal on our cozy patio or take advantage of our spacious and welcoming dining area.
Our Commitment
At Pie Guys, we take pride in:
- Quality: We use only the freshest ingredients and adhere to rigorous quality standards.
- Freshness: Dough made daily, sauces simmered to perfection, and toppings carefully selected for flavor and freshness.
- Customer Service: Our friendly staff is dedicated to providing exceptional service and memorable dining experiences.
Join us at Pie Guys and experience a slice of deliciousness, community and genuine hospitality!
Food Quality and Variety
Many reviewers praised the food at Pie Guys Pizza, with several highlighting the delicious pizzas, wings, and steak subs. Some mentioned that the Cajun wings were a must-try, while others enjoyed the dry Cajun wings. The Works pizza was also mentioned as a favorite. While some reviewers experienced issues with the size of their orders, particularly the wings, the general consensus is that the food is tasty and satisfying.
Customer Service
However, several reviewers had issues with the customer service. Some experienced long wait times, with one reviewer being told 30 minutes but waiting an additional 31 minutes. Another reviewer was told 45 minutes, but waited 45 minutes more in their car. When speaking to staff, some reviewers felt that the service was slow, unfriendly, and even rude.
Value for Money
Several reviewers felt that the prices at Pie Guys Pizza have increased, and that the quality of the food has decreased accordingly. Some reviewers were disappointed to see smaller slices and higher prices, while others felt that the prices were not justified by the quality of the food. One reviewer felt that they were ripped off after ordering 3lbs of chicken wings that ended up being much smaller than expected.
Overall Experience
While some reviewers had a generally positive experience at Pie Guys Pizza, many had issues with the customer service, food quality, and value for money. Despite some positive reviews, it seems that the business has had some inconsistencies and growing pains.
Be the first to review Pie Guys Pizzeria.
Write a Review
