Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
40 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Sunderland
Brown & Brethour Insurance Brokers has served the Sunderland, Port Perry, Uxbridge, and Lindsay communities since 1986, providing personalized insurance solutions tailored to individual needs. Our team of experienced professionals prioritizes client relationships, combining local knowledge with industry expertise to create comprehensive coverage plans for personal, business, and farm insurance. We maintain a commitment to community involvement, offering transparent communication and reliable service while adapting to evolving client needs. Our 30+ years of operation demonstrate a track record of building trust through customized protection strategies and exceptional customer support. We focus on simplifying insurance decisions through clear explanations of policy options and their practical benefits.

Our approach emphasizes long-term client relationships over transactional interactions, ensuring ongoing support as life circumstances change. The brokerage's integration with McDougall Insurance Brokers in 2022 strengthened our capacity to deliver quality service while preserving local decision-making authority. Our team's collective experience spans multiple insurance specialties, enabling holistic risk management solutions. We maintain partnerships with trusted carriers to offer competitive coverage options while maintaining personalized service standards. Our community roots ensure culturally attuned insurance guidance that reflects local priorities and challenges.
Services
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Business Insurance Farm Insurance Tenant Insurance Condo Insurance Life Insurance Travel Insurance Commercial Auto Property Insurance
Details
  • Year established: 1986
Highlights and features
  • We offer 30+ years of local insurance expertise in Durham Region
  • Our team provides personalized coverage tailored to individual needs
  • We combine community knowledge with expanded resources through McDougall Insurance
  • We maintain transparent communication with no hidden policy details
  • Our brokers hold Certified Insurance Professional designations
Services
Auto Insurance
Comprehensive vehicle coverage protecting drivers across Durham Region since 1986. Our policies cover standard automobiles, motorcycles, classic cars, and ATVs with customizable options. We help clients understand coverage limits, deductibles, and endorsements while maintaining competitive rates through trusted carrier partnerships.
Business Insurance
Tailored protection plans for Ontario businesses covering liability, property, and operational risks. We offer specialized coverage for contractors, fleet vehicles, and commercial properties while maintaining personalized service. Our brokers help businesses understand policy components like business interruption coverage and equipment breakdown protection.
Farm Insurance
Customized farm coverage addressing unique agricultural risks since 1986. Our policies protect farm homes, equipment, livestock, and operations with options for pollution liability and produce coverage. We work closely with farmers to create comprehensive plans that protect both livelihood and legacy through specialized endorsements.
Home Insurance
Residential coverage protecting homes and personal property against common risks in Sunderland and surrounding areas. We offer standard home insurance, tenant policies, and condo coverage with options for water damage and umbrella liability. Our brokers explain policy details including replacement cost provisions and personal liability limits.
Life Insurance
Financial protection solutions for families and individuals through life insurance and travel coverage. We help clients understand term vs. permanent policies while offering travel insurance for domestic and international trips. Our approach focuses on long-term financial security planning aligned with personal circumstances.
People
Jeff Brethour
Branch Manager / Sales Team
With over 30 years in the insurance industry, Jeff Brethour leads the Sunderland office with expertise in farm and commercial insurance. He holds a Bachelor of Commerce degree and Certified Insurance Brokers designation, focusing on building long-term client relationships through personalized service.
Josh Brethour
Branch Manager / Sales Team
Josh Brethour brings agricultural insurance expertise to the team, specializing in farm risk management solutions. His background in business science and insurance certifications help clients protect their farming operations while maintaining competitive coverage options.
Paul Bagshaw
Sales Team
Paul Bagshaw focuses on commercial insurance solutions, helping local businesses protect their assets through comprehensive liability and property coverage. His experience includes risk assessment for construction firms and fleet vehicle operations across Durham Region.
Jaime Brethour
Sales Team
Jaime Brethour specializes in personal insurance products, assisting clients with home, auto, and life insurance needs. Her approach emphasizes clear communication about policy details while creating customized protection plans for families in Sunderland.
Kerry Haswell
Personal Lines Supervisor
As Personal Lines Supervisor, Kerry Haswell oversees residential insurance services with expertise in vehicle coverage options. She helps clients understand policy components like collision vs. comprehensive coverage while maintaining focus on customer satisfaction.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide personal insurance (auto, home, life), business insurance (liability, property), and farm insurance. Our services also include travel insurance, tenant policies, and commercial fleet coverage.
Do you serve areas outside Sunderland?
Yes, we serve Port Perry, Uxbridge, Lindsay, and surrounding communities in Durham Region, offering both in-person and remote insurance consultation services.
How can I get a free insurance quote?
Contact us through our website or call 1-800-461-1468 to speak with a broker who will assess your needs and provide a customized quote for required coverage.
Are you part of a larger insurance network?
We merged with McDougall Insurance Brokers in 2022, maintaining local service while gaining access to expanded resources and carrier partnerships.
What makes your farm insurance different?
Our farm policies include specialized coverage options like livestock entrapment, milk contamination, and blanket machinery protection tailored to Ontario agricultural operations.
How do claims work with your brokerage?
We guide clients through the entire claims process, helping document losses and coordinating with insurance providers to ensure timely resolution of covered incidents.