Here, You're More Than a Policy Number
Protecting Your Life, Property, and Community Since 1893
Ayr Farmers Mutual Insurance Company has been a trusted name in protecting Ontario communities for over 130 years. Founded by local farmers in 1893, we remain committed to building lasting relationships with our policyholders and the communities we serve.
Our Difference
We are a Mutual Insurance Company, which means we are owned by our policyholders and work for their interests. This allows us to prioritize personalized service, local understanding, and competitive rates.
What We Offer
We provide a comprehensive range of insurance solutions to meet the unique needs of individuals, families, businesses, and farms. Our products include:
Home & Property
- Homeowners insurance
- Condo insurance
- Renters insurance
- Flood coverage
- Seasonal property insurance
Farm & Rural
- Comprehensive coverage for all types of farms and rural properties
Auto & Vehicle
- Auto insurance
- Recreational vehicle insurance
- Classic car insurance
Commercial & Business
- Business insurance for a variety of industries
- Contractor insurance
- Office insurance
- Retail insurance
Our Values
At Ayr Farmers Mutual, our core values guide us in everything we do:
- Community: We are committed to supporting and engaging with our local communities.
- Integrity: We operate with transparency and ethical practices.
- Personalized service: We provide individual attention to each policyholder.
- Experience: We leverage our expertise to offer tailored insurance solutions.
Join Us
If you're looking for an insurance provider who values relationships and understands your unique needs, contact Ayr Farmers Mutual Insurance Company today. We are dedicated to protecting what matters most to our policyholders and building strong relationships for generations to come.
Summary of Customer Reviews
Customer Satisfaction:
Customer satisfaction is generally positive, with many customers appreciating the helpfulness of their insurance agents and the company's commitment to providing rebates. Some customers also enjoyed the company's humorous signs and jokes displayed on their electronic sign.
Customer Dissatisfaction:
However, there were a few customers who experienced dissatisfaction, primarily due to difficulties with customer service and the cancellation of their insurance policy after missing a payment.
Positive Comments:
Ayr Farmers Mutual has been commended for their excellent customer service, quick responses to inquiries, and providing rebates to customers.
Negative Comments:
Customers have expressed dissatisfaction with the company's lack of consideration for individuals with disabilities and their families, as well as poor customer service experiences, such as long wait times and unhelpful staff.

Be the first to review Ayr Farmers' Mutual Insurance.
Write a Review